Elsabe Brits HISTORY-CHECK: Was Hamilton Naki directly involved with the first heart transplant?

In 2017, the City of Cape Town renamed a square to honour a black South African who assisted with the experimental work that preceded and followed the historic first heart transplant.

A persistent rumour which is often repeated, with some variation, is: A black South African man named Hamilton Naki was directly involved in the first heart transplant in December 1967 but received no credit for his work.

Numerous incorrect reports claiming that he did participate have surfaced during the past two decades. It forced some of the most prestigious newspapers, such as the New York Times, The Economist, the Associated Press, and peer review journals such as the British Medical Journal and The Lancet to publish corrections.

But who was Hamilton Naki and what role did he play in South African medical history?

Started as a university gardener

Naki was born on 26 June 1926 in Centane in the Eastern Cape and only progressed to Standard 6 (currently Grade 8) at school. His first job at the University of Cape Town was a gardener before he was noticed by Dr Robert Goetz, who had a defining influence in Naki’s life. Goetz taught him how to dissect animals and operate on them.

Professor Rosemary Hickman, a renowned and skilled surgeon who knew Naki well, wrote that “Naki had an amazing ability to learn anatomical names and recognise anomalies. His skills ranged from assisting to operating and he frequently prepared the donor animal (sometimes single-handedly) while another team worked on the recipient.”

It was in his role as laboratory assistant that Naki much later crossed paths with the Barnard brothers. Dr Christiaan Barnard had returned to South Africa in 1958 after studies abroad and began mastering the techniques of organ transplants, conducting South Africa’s first human kidney transplant in September 1964.

By 1967, Christiaan’s brother Marius had also returned from the United States. He started preparation for the first human heart transplant by working on dogs in the laboratory.

A 2014 overview article in The Bulletin of the Royal College of Surgeons of England described Naki’s role: “Naki anaesthetised the dogs for the earlier work in heart surgery in the laboratory, which was on the establishment of open heart bypass, using an external heart pump. This was a finger pump that circulated blood through heat exchangers that were warmed or cooled by huge steel tanks of water. Such pumps were difficult to maintain and often broke down unexpectedly.”

In his first interview in 30 years in 2011, Dr Marius Barnard told me that Naki was “asleep in his bed during the first heart transplant”. He said it would have been illegal and unethical to allow anyone to operate on another human without the necessary medical qualifications.

Marius and Dr Terry O’Donovan removed the heart of the first donor, Denise Darvall, which Dr Christiaan Barnard then transplanted into Louis Washkansky, achieving a world first.

Naki had ‘nimble fingers’

In 1968, Naki was moved to the laboratory of a newly founded heart transplant unit.

“He fell out, however, with an intransigent visiting French surgeon, and so when Victor Pick, then the senior assistant at [UCT’s] JS Marais laboratory, was tragically killed in a road accident, Naki was asked to return,” the Royal College of Surgeons of England’s Bulletin continued.

At the experimental surgical operating table, Naki worked on baboons, rabbits, dogs and pigs to advance the work on liver transplants, in particular. The article further mentions that he was always punctual, keen to show his skills, friendly and had “nimble fingers”.  

“As the most senior member in the laboratory, Naki came to be considered its leader and began to impart the knowledge he had acquired to a long series of trainees. He demanded high standards and became a strict taskmaster.

“Naki demonstrated dissection and surgical procedures to more than 12 trainees who were later to become professors of surgery.”

British Medical Journal retracts obituary

Before Naki’s death, he was awarded the Order of Mapungubwe in bronze by President Thabo Mbeki in 2002 and received an honorary Master of Science in Medicine degree from the University of Cape Town in 2003.

When he died on 29 May 2005, several obituaries were published locally and overseas. The British Medical Journal later had to retract their obituary because it inaccurately stated that Naki had participated in the first heart transplant, operated on humans and worked at the Groote Schuur hospital.

The then dean of UCT’s faculty of health sciences, who knew Naki at the time of the first heart transplant, wrote: “It is distressing that a fiction is gathering momentum and tarnishing the name of a highly talented and good man with an untruth. The suggestion that Hamilton Naki performed the donor operation was never mentioned in life by the man himself, by the department of cardiac surgery, or by the university in his citation for his honorary degree in 2003. It was not mentioned at his family funeral, or at the memorial service in the medical school experimental laboratory. The reason for this: it never happened.”

Commenting on the inaccurate reports, surgeon and member of the council at the University of Cape Town, Prof John Terblanche, wrote in the South African Medical Journal: “The scurrilous claims made in these obituaries belittle the very special person Hamilton Naki was.”

Netcare posthumously honoured Naki as well as the surviving team of the first heart transplant with a gold award when the new Netcare Christiaan Barnard Memorial Hospital was opened at the end of last year. The company also offers the Hamilton Naki Clinical Scholarship. In April 2017, the City of Cape Town approved the renaming of Salazar Plein on Cape Town’s foreshore to Hamilton Naki Square.

It is clear that Naki’s contribution was great, but also greatly dramatised by some media, the filmmaker Dirk de Villiers as well as the film Hidden Heart, made by Swiss writers Cristina Karrer and Werner Schweizer.

It may be true that with proper schooling, matric and eventually all the required medical qualifications, Hamilton Naki would have become a surgeon.

He had the interest and dedication but the circumstances, and of course apartheid, was against him.

The hallowed halls of a medical school were closed to someone like him. And that is the painful truth about Hamilton Naki.

Elsabe Brits is a science journalist at Netwerk24.

© Copyright Africa Check 2020. Read our republishing guidelines. You may reproduce this piece or content from it for the purpose of reporting and/or discussing news and current events. This is subject to: Crediting Africa Check in the byline, keeping all hyperlinks to the sources used and adding this sentence at the end of your publication: “This report was written by Africa Check, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the original piece on their website", with a link back to this page.

Comment on this report

Comments 5
  1. By Jose de Nobrega FRCS(Edin)

    CORRECTION – The Donor Chest in B Theatre was opened via a Median Sternotomy with 4 (Four) surgeons in attendance – Terry O.Donovan, Francois Hitchcock, Hannes Meyer, and Marius Barnard. Professor Barnard himself scrubbed in to open the pericardium, complete the dissection from the Ascending Aorta, the Pulmonary Artery down to its bifurcation, the Vena Cavae entering the Right Atrium, and the Pulmonary Veins entering the Left Atrium at the back of the Heart. He then removed the Heart himself. The Heart was placed in a metal bowl containing a Warm Balanced Salt Solution and the Transplant was completed by Barnard, with Hewitson First Assistant, and O’Donovan, Meyer,and Hitchcock at the table. Marius Barnard was not at the table.

    0
    -9
    vote
    Reply Report comment
  2. By Luvo

    Mxm. What about Hamilton Naki. If Christian Barnard was the surgeon who performed the first heart transplant why did he not win the Nobel price for such a high class achievement? There is something fishy about this whole story. There is a lot of controversy here.

    +7
    -9
    vote
    Reply Report comment
  3. By Francine Harbour

    I am an American (61) who has been following South African news off and on for years, moreso now because of Trevor Noah and his very helpful comparison of Trump to the rise of African (and other) dictators, among other things.

    Most well-educated Americans know about the Barnards, but I did not know about Hamilton Naki or the controversy. I certainly agree that but for aparteid, Naki could have become a world reknown heart surgeon and pioneer.

    You probably know that in the U.S., February is Black History awareness month. I live in Anchorage, Alaska, which has a higher Black population than you might think. Over 3,600 of the U.S. Army Engineer soldiers worked on the construction of the Alaska-Canada Highway,1,387 mi (2,232 km) long, after the attack on Pearl Harbor, Hawaii, in December 1941. Many of these engineers came back and settled in Anchorage after the war and their children and grandchildren remain.

    Next black history month, in February 2019, I would like to try to get the story of Hamilton Naki included in the community activities. I think there would be a receptive audience here. What would you suggest as the best resources to study about Mr. Naki?
    Thank you, Francine Harbour, Anchorage, Alaska, USA

    +3
    -2
    vote
    Reply Report comment
  4. By Richard Mabena

    Besides his experience, talents, knowledge and skills; why was Dr. Naki excluded f4om this historic occassion? If that that was the case at all.

    +1
    0
    vote
    Reply Report comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Africa Check encourages frank, open, inclusive discussion of the topics raised on the website. To ensure the discussion meets these aims we have established some simple House Rules for contributions. Any contributions that violate the rules may be removed by the moderator.

Contributions must:

  • Relate to the topic of the report or post
  • Be written mainly in English

Contributions may not:

  • Contain defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or harassing language or material;
  • Encourage or constitute conduct which is unlawful;
  • Contain material in respect of which another party holds the rights, where such rights have not be cleared by you;
  • Contain personal information about you or others that might put anyone at risk;
  • Contain unsuitable URLs;
  • Constitute junk mail or unauthorised advertising;
  • Be submitted repeatedly as comments on the same report or post;

By making any contribution you agree that, in addition to these House Rules, you shall be bound by Africa Check's Terms and Conditions of use which can be accessed on the website.

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.