Alphonce Shiundu COMMENT: 10 key lessons learned in Kenya, one year on

Our Kenya editor had to hit the ground sprinting a year ago. Now that Alphonce Shiundu managed to catch his breath, he distilled his experience into 10 key lessons.

This time last year, Kenya’s elections and the polarising political rhetoric that accompanied the campaigns were months away. The now-popular term “fake news” was also relatively unknown in the Kenyan political context.

And regular fact-checking of public claims did not yet exist.

It is against this backdrop that I started working as Africa Check’s first full-time fact-checker in Kenya. The mission was straightforward: To keep public debate honest.

I thought fact-checkers viewed the world in black or white. But there are nuances, context and the all-important “what-would-be-the-impact-if-this-claim-is-left-unchecked”-question to think about.

Fact-checking is painstaking, but always exhilarating when you finally reach a verdict that is defendable with evidence and expert knowledge.

From the more than 40 fact-checking pieces I delivered from in Kenya, I learned invaluable lessons. Here are my top ten.

  1. Just because it’s official, doesn’t mean it’s a fact

How can it be that a presidential speech, prepared by many presumably highly-qualified hands and minds, end up with inaccuracies?

Right from my very first fact-check of police numbers in Kenya, I found this astounding.

I expected the government would have its numbers right because after all, they have an army of record-keepers and a whole government statistics body crunching the data.

But the numbers were sometimes wrong, misrepresented or outdated and I learned to double-check everything.

  1. The credibility test

While every fact-check is different, the process of compiling it is set and replicable.

I had people giving off-the-record nuggets about closed-door meetings or classified documents. They were often disappointed when I didn’t quote their “evidence”.

In fact-checking, every source of information has to be vetted and its accuracy tested. And it has to be public so that people reading the fact-check can reach the same conclusion by following the same evidence. The International Fact-checking Network’s code of principles – that Africa Check subscribes to – requires such transparency of sources.

The network also requires it of funding. Initially, some critics questioned whose agenda we were serving, but it died down when they learned that Africa Check’s sources of funding aren’t secret.

  1. Fact-checking takes time

When I started out, there wasn’t much in Africa Check’s fact-checking bank for Kenya. Now that a year has passed, we can turn around fact-checks on issues we have checked before much quicker.

Many who asked us to do “live fact-checking” at the beginning did not grasp the kind of legwork required to reach a verdict about a claim. At times, a fact-check would take weeks to put together. (Note: More about this in lesson 5, 9 and 10!)

  1. Talking heads aren’t experts

Finding subject-matter experts to help unpack a claim hasn’t been easy. Some of the garrulous television pundits are just that – talking heads. They were ready to deliver sound-bites and great quotes without really illuminating an issue.

We had to reach university professors with a track-record of research in the particular subject or known think-tanks with hands-on knowledge of a specific issue, such as the Institute of Economic Affairs, Tegemeo Institute and the International Budget Partnership.

Sadly, some senior people in universities with wonderful scholarly track-records just didn’t have the time to speak to fact-checkers. Or so they said.

  1. Oh dear, the bureaucracy!

The Kenya National Bureau of Statistics, the government’s statistics agency, makes lots of insightful data publicly available. So does the Central Bank.

But our fact-check of Kenya’s unemployment rate is still up in the air. Back in May, the statistics bureau promised us its latest report would be available “in a month”. That month turned into months and it’s now more than half a year later.

There are things the bureau just can’t do without an okay from the parent ministry or minister, so I was told. We wait.

  1. Be fair, not ‘balanced’

In fact-checking, you don’t have to “balance” differing views. Fairness is shown by contacting claim-makers to ask for proof, verifying their proof and then returning to them with evidence to either support or discredit the claim.

We furthermore try, over time, to fact-check all sides in a matter – for example, by looking into the ruling party’s election manifesto and also the opposition’s promises.

  1. We aren’t fortune tellers or psychics

The rule is simple: We can’t fact-check the future or beliefs. So, if a politician promises free secondary education, we cannot predict whether it will be fulfilled or not. However, we can set out how much money would be needed to do so.

  1. The power of collaboration

Keeping public debate honest requires many partners. Consumers of information need the facts presented in a simple, coherent and complete manner and in a variety of formats

Africa Check’s weekly slot on the KTN prime-time show #Checkpoint with Yvonne Okwara-Matole helped inform viewers about claims in the major manifestos. We also taught the public how to be smart online and how to interpret opinion polls.

Our weekly podcast with BBC Africa’s Dickens Olewe was another outlet for enhancing debate. I also got to share our work with many local and international media houses – being interviewed at least 14 times in the month running up to the election alone!

  1. The excuses & attacks

As we dig for the facts at Africa Check, we turn over rocks, stones and even pebbles. Not everyone is equally helpful as we do so.

When I called the chief executive of the Kenya Investment Authority for data on foreign direct investment, he asked me to be patient as the authority’s building has not had power for weeks. But the promised response never came.

Then there was the time I called the spokesman for Kenya’s opposition leader Raila Odinga. The question was straightforward: where did Odinga source his quoted price of maize from?

Dennis Onyango responded: “We are not going to do your research for you. We stand by what he said, that the maize is costing KSh4,600 per bag. If you haven’t got it, that is not our problem!” (Note: Read the resulting report here.)

When we fact-checked a speech by labour union leader Wilson Sossion, I had a long conversation with him. He didn’t provide evidence for his claim that 70% of youth in Kenya were unemployed, but kept insisting: “I was right!”

I’ve lost count of the number of times I had to introduce myself, explain what Africa Check does, give examples of our previous work and even after all that, be told: “Call me later, I am in a meeting!” And that would be the last of it.

  1. ‘Never give up’

This is one of the most memorable “commandments” we have at Africa Check. You don’t give up when you are ignored and you don’t give up until you find the original footage, document or speech. You don’t give up until a fact-check is complete and you have a credible verdict.

For instance, we attempted to verify the kilometres of roads built during the Kenyatta government’s first term. Every source provided conflicting data: different government agencies as well as the ministry of transport and infrastructure.

The minister referred us to the presidential delivery unit, who referred us to the ministry officials, who again referred us to the minister, who referred us back to the unit. Engineering associations did not come to light either. But trust me, I’m not giving up!

Edited by Anim van Wyk

 

© Copyright Africa Check 2017. You may reproduce this piece or content from it for the purpose of reporting and/or discussing news and current events. This is subject to: Crediting Africa Check in the byline, keeping all hyperlinks to the sources used and adding this sentence at the end of your publication: “This report was written by Africa Check, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the original piece on their website", with a link back to this page.

Comment on this report

Comments 1
  1. By D. Nene

    Wow, Wow, The Kenya we want, not even the President and his dupty, the Late Waweru Mburu of Royal Media,,
    Summed everything for us, Fake people, fake leaders and fake Kenyans. What I know, in Kenya, nothing stands straight. To get any Fact in Kenya is as the saying goes, look for a needle in a hay sack@ Corruption! I believe even the president is Corrupt!

    vote
    Reply Report comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Africa Check encourages frank, open, inclusive discussion of the topics raised on the website. To ensure the discussion meets these aims we have established some simple House Rules for contributions. Any contributions that violate the rules may be removed by the moderator.

Contributions must:

  • Relate to the topic of the report or post
  • Be written mainly in English

Contributions may not:

  • Contain defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or harassing language or material;
  • Encourage or constitute conduct which is unlawful;
  • Contain material in respect of which another party holds the rights, where such rights have not be cleared by you;
  • Contain personal information about you or others that might put anyone at risk;
  • Contain unsuitable URLs;
  • Constitute junk mail or unauthorised advertising;
  • Be submitted repeatedly as comments on the same report or post;

By making any contribution you agree that, in addition to these House Rules, you shall be bound by Africa Check's Terms and Conditions of use which can be accessed on the website.

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.