Back to Africa Check

REPORT CARD: South African president Ramaphosa’s claims about the state of the nation

With Cyril Ramaphosa set to give his fifth state of the nation address today, we look back at the president’s claims in the past two years – and suggest tools you can use to check the speech yourself.

South African president Cyril Ramaphosa is set to deliver his fifth state of the nation address (Sona) on 11 February 2021. The speech traditionally outlines the government’s progress so far, and its plans for the next financial year. 

Covid-19 restrictions mean a limited number of people will attend the event in parliament. And some ceremonial aspects, such as the red carpet procession, have been scrapped.  

As in previous years, Africa Check will listen out for key claims by the president. Will he stay on the right side of the facts? Tune in to find out. 

That said, we now examine Ramaphosa’s Sona track record.  We look back at some of the claims (and a promise) he made in the last two addresses – and give updates.

Sona 2018: ‘Making your future work better – learning from Madiba’

The 2018 state of the nation address was postponed for more than a week as the presidency changed hands from Jacob Zuma to Ramaphosa. 

Ramaphosa’s maiden address, delivered with reference to Nelson Mandela, touched on key issues such as education, employment and poverty. Africa Check examined 12 of his claims and found 10 to be correct, and two incorrect.

Claim: ‘Our state employs some one million public servants.’

Verdict: Incorrect

The national treasury keeps payroll records of public servants in South Africa. 

The figures are measured in “full-time equivalents”. This means a temporary or contract worker who receives fewer than 12 salaries a year is not counted as one full-time employee. Instead, their contributions are combined into full-time equivalents.

For example, two people working full-time for six months in a year count as one full-time equivalent.

Employment in national and provincial government departments grew rapidly between 2001/02 and 2011/12. It peaked at 1,327,231 full-time equivalent positions in 2012/13. The most recent data puts the number of full-time equivalent government employees at 1.3 million, in 2019/20.

full time employees

 

State agency Statistics South Africa tracks quarterly employment statistics. These show that from the fourth quarter of 2009 to the fourth quarter of 2019, public servant numbers grew from 1,780,553 to 2,108,125 – an increase of 327,572.

gov employees

 

These totals are made up of figures from national, provincial and local government departments, universities and technikons, and extra-budgetary institutions such as the South African Revenue Service, the Road Accident Fund and the Unemployment Insurance Fund

Tip: Consider comparing different data sources to evaluate claims. You may need to consult an expert to check which set of data is more accurate. This will help you get the full picture. 

Promise: ‘We will initiate an additional 2 million people on antiretroviral treatment by December 2020.’

Verdict: Likely broken

Antiretroviral treatment (ART) helps control HIV, protecting people living with the virus from developing Aids.

Ramaphosa’s promise was, effectively, that nearly 6.2 million people would have ART by December 2020. He made the commitment at the end of the 2017/18 financial year. That year, the health department reported that an estimated 4,189,070 people were on ART.  

The department’s latest data estimates that 4.7 million people were on ART in July 2019 – an increase of just 510,930.  

To hit Ramaphosa’s target of 6.2 million, the number of people on treatment would have had to increase by 1,500,000 from July 2019 to December 2020. But data for this period is not yet available.

Estimates from the health department suggest that Ramaphosa’s promise may have been ambitious. The department aims to have 6,100,000 people on treatment by March 2021.

Tip: Promises with targets set in the future are difficult to check. But we can log promises and track their progress over time. Visit our Promise Tracker to find out how.   

Sona 2019: ‘Let's grow South Africa together as we celebrate 25 years of freedom’

Ramaphosa delivered his second state of the nation address on 7 February 2019. It was also the fifth and final address of the existing administration before the national election in May.

Africa Check looked at 12 claims in the address. Eight were correct and the rest a mixture of mostly correct, unproven and understated. We revisit two.

Claim: ‘Since the launch of the Safe initiative, 699 schools have been provided with safe and appropriate sanitation facilities and projects and a further 1,150 schools are either in planning, design or construction stages.’

Verdict: Unproven 

The Sanitation Appropriate For Education (Safe) initiative was launched on 14 August 2018. Its main objective is to replace unsafe pit latrines at schools with better, safer toilets. 

A government audit of schools in May and June 2018 found that, nationwide, the only toilets available at 3,898 schools were pit latrines. Another 3,040 had “proper sanitation”, but still had pit toilets on their grounds. 

The basic education department told Africa Check that Ramaphosa’s figures were from December 2018. Since then, 88 more schools had been upgraded, bringing the total to 787, spokesperson Troy Martens said. 

But the education-focused civil society organisations Equal Education and Section 27 told Africa Check it was difficult to independently verify the department’s numbers. 

What do the figures look like today? In a December 2020 written reply to a parliamentary question, basic education minister Angie Motshekga said that of the 3,898 schools identified, 427 had closed down. A further 725 schools were assessed and found to have adequate toilets.  

The remaining 2,747 schools needed intervention, she said. Upgrade work at 612 of those schools had reached “practical completion”, while construction continued at a further 420. 

But, as with Ramaphosa’s claim, it is difficult to independently verify these figures. 

Tip: To assess claims about projects that span years, check if the individual figures add up. You may need to look at several reports and other documents to do this.  

Claim: ‘We have launched the Youth Employment Service, which is placing unemployed youth in paid internships in companies across the country.’

Verdict: Correct

The government’s Youth Employment Service was launched in March 2018 with the aim of creating a million jobs for young people using “innovation and technological best practice”.

The initiative is a partnership between the government, business, labour and civil society. It is meant to provide work experience, job placements (or the option for businesses to “sponsor” work placements) and training for people aged 18 to 35. 

By February 2019, 319 companies had registered for the service but only 6,939 “work experiences” had been confirmed. 

Today – in February 2021 – 1,305 companies have registered and more than 47,158 work experiences have been created. “These numbers change on a daily basis,” Youth Employment Service spokesperson Mokebe Thulo told Africa Check.  

Join us! Here’s how to be a fact-checker

Want to fact-check claims in Ramaphosa’s speech tonight? These data sources may be useful:

  • Annual reports help verify claims to do with government departments. You can usually find them on department websites under “documentation” or “resources”. 
  • Statistics South Africa collects information on a range of topics. Its general household survey, published each year, will help you check claims about the living conditions of people living in South Africa.  
  • The Parliamentary Monitoring Group publishes reports on the meetings of more than 50 parliamentary committees. It is handy for finding updates on the progress of government projects.
  • World Bank Open Data includes current and historical statistics by country and indicator. For example, you can see the changes in South Africa’s gross domestic product since 1960. You can also compare data across regions. 
  • Claims about changes in prices, salaries, budgets and more need to be adjusted to account for inflation. This South African inflation calculator does the work for you. For claims involving percentage increases or decreases, this calculator works out the change from one number to another.

We want to hear from you

Will you be listening to the state of the nation address on Thursday evening? Send us the claims you think need fact-checking. Talk to us on Twitter (tweet @africacheck using #SONAfactcheck) or email [email protected].

Further Reading

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
limit: 600 characters