The articles are identical, one published on tech news site My Broadband and the other on News365. Both open: “Johannesburg, which promotes itself as a world class African city, has only one working fire truck.”
But does Johannesburg really only have one working fire truck? The answer is complicated.
Claim disputed by Johannesburg fire services
Robert Mulaudzi, spokesperson for the City of Johannesburg’s emergency services, told Rapport that the city had more than one working fire truck. He said the city usually had between seven and 11 working trucks.
But Engelbrecht told Rapport: “Daar is vyf. Drie staan permanent, een werk af en toe, wat beteken daar is net een wat permanent aan diens is.” This roughly translates as: “There are five. Three are permanently out of service, one works now and then, which means there is just one which is permanently on duty.”
Rapport claims that in comparison, Cape Town has bought 133 new fire trucks over the past two years.
According to the most recent data, from Statistics South Africa’s Community Survey in 2016, Johannesburg has a larger population than Cape Town, by approximately a million people.
When Africa Check contacted Mulaudzi, he claimed that Johannesburg is currently running five working fire engines, and claims that in the previous months the number “never went below four”.
Fire stations confirm at least two working fire engines
Africa Check phoned five Johannesburg fire stations that are meant to have access to a working fire engine. Three did not answer our calls, although the two that did, in Lonehill and Alexandra, both confirmed that they had access to a working fire engine.
A staff member at Lonehill station said its fire truck was actually used by several nearby stations because of the shortage of engines, though Alexandra station was not among them.
Both stations confirmed that their fire engines had been operating since at least January, so both would have been operational when the Rapport article was published.
City of Johannesburg does have fire engine shortage
The most recent available data released by the City of Johannesburg is in its report on the 2018/19 financial year. The report notes that in 2018/19 the city’s emergency services operated with about eight engines. These were distributed across the city’s six emergency services districts to ensure at least one per district.
In July 2019, under then executive mayor Herman Mashaba, the city announced that it would be buying several new emergency vehicles, which would “result in the 30 fire stations in the city each receiving a new fire engine”.
Mashaba admitted at the time that Johannesburg had only seven fire engines.
The city’s current executive mayor Geoff Makhubo said in February 2020 that the city had only five fire engines.
Claim shared further by opposition party
The claim that Johannesburg has only one fire truck has spread further in a graphic posted several times to Facebook and Twitter, comparing Johannesburg to Cape Town. According to the graphic, Cape Town has 64 fire trucks.
The graphic credits this to the “DA difference”. It is branded with the logo of the Democratic Alliance, or DA, South Africa’s main opposition party.
For publishers: what to do if your post is rated false
A fact-checker has rated your Facebook or Instagram post as “false”, “altered”, “partly false” or “missing context”. This could have serious consequences. What do you do?
Click on our guide for the steps you should follow.Publishers guide
Africa Check teams up with Facebook
Africa Check is a partner in Meta's third-party fact-checking programme to help stop the spread of false information on social media.
The content we rate as “false” will be downgraded on Facebook and Instagram. This means fewer people will see it.
You can also help identify false information on Facebook. This guide explains how.