Teenage white girl to be tried as 300-pound black man in the USA? Satire helps us understand injustice
It’s a report on the murder trial of one Hannah Stephenson, a 16-year-old girl accused of stabbing a classmate to death, with a screwdriver, in Detroit, Michigan. The video shows a weeping white teenager sitting in court between her unhappy parents.
Hannah has been given “the harshest possible sentencing”, the news anchor says.
“She will be tried as a black adult.”
The video cuts to the judge: “Due to the extreme and violent nature of this crime, the court finds it fitting to try the defendant as an African American.”
The news anchor continues: “Once the trial begins next week, all courtroom images of Hannah will depict her as a 300-pound muscular black man. And jury members will be instructed to imagine her as such.”
‘I couldn’t believe what I was hearing’
Comments on the South African Facebook user’s post showed outrage.
“This lets you now they been f***g us throughout time.”
“Sad that we are viewed by the colour of our skin. The judge should be disbarred and every case of his should be investigated.”
“Just a fact that being a black person, you are charged with higher sentences.”
“WTF. They said picture her as a 300lb black man. I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. That is really f***d up!”
But other comments pointed to what it is: satire.
What is satire?
Satire uses humour to show that injustices are ridiculous. In this case, the injustice is that, in the USA, black people are more likely to receive far harsher sentences, for the same crime, than white people.
The video was produced by the Onion back in 2011. The Onion, originally a print newspaper, has been publishing satire on American society since the late 1980s.
The “joke” is that the white teenager would only get the punishment she deserved for an “extreme and violent” crime if she were tried as “a 300-pound muscular black man”.
Does satire point to a real problem?
Are black people really given harsher sentences than white people in the USA?
Yes, according to academic articles, news reports, government studies and global organisations.
In 2018 the Pacific Standard reported that “significant racial disparities persist in all aspects of the American criminal justice system, according to a UN Sentencing Project study. The report finds discrimination against people of colour in the policing, pretrial, sentencing, parole, and post-prison stages of the country's justice system.”
In 2017 the Washington Post revealed that a study by the US Sentencing Commission had found that black men convicted of the same crimes as white men received federal prison sentences that were, on average, nearly 20% longer.
A 2014 University of Michigan study concluded that “blacks receive sentences that are almost 10 percent longer than those of comparable whites arrested for the same crimes”.
The people who commented on the Facebook post weren’t wrong to be outraged. That’s the power of satire. – Mary Alexander (11/02/19)
Republish our content for free
For publishers: what to do if your post is rated false
A fact-checker has rated your Facebook or Instagram post as “false”, “altered”, “partly false” or “missing context”. This could have serious consequences. What do you do?
Click on our guide for the steps you should follow.Publishers guide
Africa Check teams up with Facebook
Africa Check is a partner in Meta's third-party fact-checking programme to help stop the spread of false information on social media.
The content we rate as “false” will be downgraded on Facebook and Instagram. This means fewer people will see it.
You can also help identify false information on Facebook. This guide explains how.