Did Zuma keep his word? Tracking past State of the Nation address promises

Comments 3

South Africa’s President Jacob Zuma is due to give his 2016 State of the Nation address at the opening of parliament next week. Africa Check reviewed his previous addresses to assess if he kept promises made then.

South Africa’s third democratically elected president took office in 2009. President Jacob Zuma has since delivered eight State of the Nation addresses. Africa Check went through his speeches and selected a promise from each year to check whether it has been achieved.

Our requirements were that the promise had to be checkable, meaning that we needed to be able to locate publicly available information against which to verify it and that the promises covered the spectrum of issues concerning South Africans.

Water

2015: “…government through the department of water and sanitation will train 15,000 artisans or plumbers who will fix leaking taps in their local communities.”

Verdict: In progress

Residents of Nongoma in KwaZulu-Natal prepare to collect water from a free water point sponsored by concerned citizens in November 2015. Photo: AFP /MUJAHID SAFODIEN
Residents of Nongoma in KwaZulu-Natal prepare to collect water from a free water point sponsored by concerned citizens in November 2015. Photo: AFP /Mujahid Safodien

Zuma made this commitment on 12 February 2015.

In August the department of water and sanitation launched their “War on Leaks” project.

Phase 1, to be completed in the 2015/16 financial year, will train 3,000 artisans, plumbers and water agents. (A water agent educates the public on how to use water wisely and manage water resources.)

An additional 5,000 people will begin training in the 2016/17 financial year (phase 2) and 7,000 will begin training in 2017/18 (phase 3).

Spokesman for the department, Mlimandlela Ndamase, told Africa Check that 2,897 people were receiving training as of 25 January this year. This included 1,573 artisans, 243 plumbers and 1,081 water agents.

However, the artisans and plumbers need 3 years of training before they will be able to start working, while the water agentscan begin work after 10 months of training.

Education

2014: “We… will continue to eradicate mud schools and other inappropriate structures.”

Verdict: In progress

A child walks to school in June 2013 in a village outside the town of Mthatha in South Africa's Eastern Cape province. Photo: AFP/Jennifer Bruce
A child walks to school in June 2013 in a village outside the town of Mthatha in South Africa’s Eastern Cape province. Photo: AFP/Jennifer Bruce

Zuma made this commitment on 17 June 2014.

South Africa’s department of basic education is replacing mud schools and other inappropriate structures under the Accelerated Schools Infrastructure Delivery Initiative (ASIDI).

The ASIDI programme, which was launched by the department in 2011, initially identified 496 schools that were considered “inappropriate structures”. Of those schools, 50 were meant to be replaced in 2011/12, 100 in 2012/13 and the last 346 in 2013/14.

However, the programme has fallen far behind its target.

Data sent to Africa Check by the spokesman for the department of basic education, Elijah Mhlanga, revealed that the number of schools to be rebuilt has increased to 510. The  majority of them are located in the Eastern Cape.

By 31 December last year only a quarter (134 schools) had been rebuilt.

Justice

2013: “To further boost the fight against corruption, we will fill all vacant posts at the upper echelons of the criminal justice system.”

Our verdict: Not achieved

Zuma made this commitment on 14 February 2013. At that time both South Africa’s National Prosecuting Authority and Special Investigating Unit did not have permanent heads.

Almost seven months later, on 1 October 2013, Zuma appointed Mxolisi Nxasana as the national director of public prosecutions and Vas Soni as the head of the Special Investigating Unit.

In July 2014, Zuma announced that he was instituting an inquiry into Nxasana’s fitness to hold office. The inquiry was called off by Zuma in mid-May of 2015 and Nxasana resigned from his position on 31 May.

Silas Ramaite was appointed as acting national director of public prosecutions on 1 June 2015. Zuma permanently appointed Shaun Abrahams on 18 June 2015.

Soni resigned as head of the Special Investigating Unit in February 2015. A permanent appointment was not made and Gerhard Visagie was appointed as the acting head.

Executive secretary of the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution, Lawson Naidoo, told Africa Check that Zuma’s appointments since his 2013 commitment had “not brought stability to the institutions or strengthened them”.

CASAC, which works to protect and uphold South Africa’s constitution, lodged a formal application in the constitutional court in 2013 to compel Zuma to appoint a permanent NPA head.

Energy

2012: “The government target is 1 million solar geysers by 2014/2015.”

Verdict: Not achieved

Solar-powered heaters installed by Eskom on the roofs of homes in the township of Demat, south of Durban, to help ease pressure on the grid. The company says it aims to install one million solar water heaters throughout country by 2015. Photo AFP/Rajesh Jantilal
Solar-powered heaters installed by Eskom on the roofs of homes in the township of Demat, south of Durban. Photo AFP/Rajesh Jantilal

Government’s project to install one million solar geysers was announced in 2009 by then minister of energy Dipuo Peters in a budget vote speech.

“The department will ensure that 1 million solar water heaters are installed in households and commercial buildings over a period of five years,” she said.

By the end of the 2014/2015 financial year, the department of energy reported that a total of 412,959 solar water heater units had been installed.

Project manager of the department’s renewable energy initiative, Khanyiso Zihlangu, could not tell us as of 2016, how many solar water heaters had been installed under this project.

“A process of verifying and validating the figures is scheduled to kick-off in the next financial year,” he said.

Women

2011: “Given our emphasis on women’s health, we will broaden the scope of reproductive health rights and provide services related to… sanitary towels for the indigent.”

Verdict: Not achieved

Fabric and material used to make reusable sanitary pads at a sewing factory in Durban. Photo: AFP/STEFAN HEUNIS
Fabric and material used to make reusable sanitary pads at a sewing factory in Durban. Photo: AFP/STEFAN HEUNIS

Zuma made this commitment on 10 February 2011.

A few days later, the department of women, children and people with disabilities (now the department of women) announced that it would launch the “Sanitary Dignity Campaign” to hand out sanitary towels to women and girls who could not afford them.

Community journalism website GroundUp followed up on Zuma’s promise in 2014 and 2015 but could find no evidence of the programme having been launched.

Media liaison officer at the department of women, Charlotte Lobe, directed questions to the department of social development.

The department’s media liaison officer, Jaconia Kobue, told Africa Check that they did not have a policy or programme in place to provide sanitary towels to women and girls.

“The department will get sanitary towel donations from companies and give them out every now and then,” Kobue said. However, they did not monitor how many sanitary towels had been donated or how many women and girls had received them.

The department of basic education told Africa Check that it had entered into partnerships to “provide material support to learners, including sanitary ware to girls in some instances”. But they could not say how many school girls had received sanitary towels as part of this.

Crime

2010:We are implementing plans to increase the number of policemen and women by 10% over the next three years.”

Verdict: Not achieved

South African Police forces charge students on the south lawn of the Union Building in Pretoria during a protest against university fee hikes on October 23, 2015. Photo: AFP/ Mujahid Safodien
South African Police forces charge students at the Union Building in Pretoria during a protest against university fee hikes on October 23, 2015. Photo: AFP/ Mujahid Safodien

Zuma’s commitment was made on 11 February 2010, during the 2009/10 financial year.

The South African Police Service (SAPS) reported that they employed 190,199 people at the end of 2009/10.

Of these, 151,164 were police officials and 39,035 were Public Service Act employees (who perform support functions such as personnel administration, procurement, financial administration, typing and cleaning).

A 10% increase would have seen the number of police officials increase to 166,280.

But by 2012/13, their numbers only stood at 155,531 – an increase of just 2.9%. The latest data from 2014/15 showed that the number of police officials has decreased by 0.1% since Zuma made the commitment.


However, even if Zuma had kept his promise to increase police numbers by 10% it may not have helped to tackle South Africa’s crime problem.

Postdoctoral research fellow at the University of Cape Town’s criminology department, Dr Andrew Faull, told Africa Check that more police officials don’t always result in better policing and less crime.

“Police officials need to be deployed and managed properly along with targeted interventions and programmes. As importantly, they should be seen as legitimate authorities enforcing legitimate laws fairly and equitably,” said Faull.

“Conversely, illegitimate police practices can promote crime and disorder. In this case, the fewer police officials there are, the better.”

Jobs

2009: “The second phase of the [Expanded Public Works Programme] aims to create about four million job opportunities by 2014.”

Verdict: Achieved

Workers walk on February 11, 2010 on a construction site on Durban's Golden Mile Beach. Photo: AFP/ Rajesh Jantilal
Workers walk on a construction site on Durban’s Golden Mile Beach on February 11, 2010. Photo: AFP/ Rajesh Jantilal

Zuma made this commitment in his first state of the nation address on 3 June 2009.

By March 2014, the second phase of the Expanded Public Works Programme had created 4,071,292 work opportunities figures from the department of public works show.

It is important to remember though that work opportunities are not permanent jobs and in most cases only last a few months.

The department of public works notes that “the same individual can be employed on different projects and each period of employment will be counted as a work opportunity”. So while 4,071,292 work opportunities were created this does not mean that the same number of people benefited from the programme.

And though Zuma promised “four million job opportunities by 2014”, the Expanded Public Works Programme itself aimed higherto create 4.5 million work opportunitiesand this was not achieved.

Edited by Anim van Wyk

Additional research by Lebohang Mojapelo

© Copyright Africa Check 2016. You may reproduce this report or content from it for the purpose of reporting and/or discussing news and current events, subject to providing a credit to "Africa Check a non-partisan organisation which promotes accuracy in public debate and the media. Twitter @AfricaCheck and www.africacheck.org".

Comment on this report

Comments 3
  1. By Derrick

    The only way to have crime under control was to first restore good relationship between the cops and the communities . As things stands police are regarded as enemies of the community and none of the police commisioners has tried to fix that since the advent of democracy.

    vote
    Reply Report comment
  2. By Chris

    Don’t forget the promise when he took over from Thabo Mbeki as president: that before the end of the year the ANC would have created 500 000 jobs. Instead, by the end of the year the same number of jobs were lost.

    vote
    Reply Report comment
  3. By Oddballons

    The verdicts for promises made in numbers could be better reported as fractions of what’s promised. For example, if 500 jobs were promised and only 100 created, 100/500 would give immediate verdict without searching through the text. Sorry, I’m clearly lazy 🙂

    vote
    Reply Report comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Africa Check encourages frank, open, inclusive discussion of the topics raised on the website. To ensure the discussion meets these aims we have established some simple House Rules for contributions. Any contributions that violate the rules may be removed by the moderator.

Contributions must:

  • Relate to the topic of the report or post
  • Be written mainly in English

Contributions may not:

  • Contain defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or harassing language or material;
  • Encourage or constitute conduct which is unlawful;
  • Contain material in respect of which another party holds the rights, where such rights have not be cleared by you;
  • Contain personal information about you or others that might put anyone at risk;
  • Contain unsuitable URLs;
  • Constitute junk mail or unauthorised advertising;
  • Be submitted repeatedly as comments on the same report or post;

By making any contribution you agree that, in addition to these House Rules, you shall be bound by Africa Check's Terms and Conditions of use which can be accessed on the website.

*