Could Cape Town’s Table Mountain have claimed more lives than Mount Everest?
This claim appeared in an article published by the UK edition of the International Business Times. It recounted a fatal New Year’s Day accident on Table Mountain which claimed the lives of a tourist and her local guide.
The Cape Town attraction is “deadlier than the world’s highest peak”, the article stated, having claimed 218 lives in the past 100 years.
The claim seems to be from the South African National Parks website. Cautioning would-be visitors to the Table Mountain National Park, SANParks’ site notes that “more people die on Table Mountain than Mount Everest. Table Mountain is a mountain, not a hill! Please respect and enjoy your mountain.”
We asked SANParks’ regional communications manager for the Cape Region, Merle Collins, for the data on which this claim was based. She responded following publication.
“After extensive consultation with park management please be advised that Table Mountain is an open access area with hundreds of access points and routes and that we are unable to assist with your request. Furthermore, the two mountains are completely different (height, numbers of visitors, topography, temperature, snow, accessibility, weather, oxygen etc.) and comparisons/claims of this nature are not necessary.”
(Note: The claim has not been taken down from the Table Mountain National Park website yet.)
251 deaths on Table Mountain counted to date
The South African Mountain Accident Database is described as “one of the few sources which consistently kept records of mountaineering incidents, accidents and deaths across the Cape Peninsula and Table Mountain”.
It provides statistics dating back to 1653 when a Dutch sailor named Johann Merklein dislocated his arm while descending Platteklip Gorge, Andrew Lewis told Africa Check.
Lewis is the database’s current curator and a member of the University of Cape Town’s Information and Communication Technology staff. It “is in no ways complete”, its developers caution, though they do put in every effort to keep the database’s records as comprehensive as possible.
“Deaths from crime and exposure [in the case of homeless people] occur that we are not aware of,” Lewis said, as these mostly occur between the suburbs and lower slopes.
The database is primarily populated with data from the Mountain Club of South Africa’s 13 nationwide search and rescue teams. Historical data is supplemented from archives, Lewis noted.
In total, 251 deaths on Table Mountain have been recorded to date. “From [the database], you can see that most fatalities on Table Mountain come from falls, medical issues and rockfall,” Lewis told Africa Check.
288 deaths recorded on Mount Everest
The figure for Table Mountain is lower than the 288 deaths recorded for Mount Everest above 5,000 m, Richard Salisbury told Africa Check.
The database’s primary sources are expedition interviews conducted by Elizabeth Hawley, a former journalist and current director emeritus of the database. Data from these interviews is supplemented with “information gathered from books, alpine journals and correspondence with Himalayan climbers”.
All expeditions between 1905 and 2017 are recorded, the site states. Earlier data is recorded for select expeditions.
Comparison ‘utterly meaningless’
“[T]he comparison is as sensational as it is inconsequential,” Lewis told Africa Check.
“One needs to take into account the total number of people accessing Table Mountain and Mount Everest. This is not possible on Table Mountain as there is no controlled access, so a comparison of these two numbers is utterly meaningless.”
When absolute figures are considered, “it is very likely that the answer may be time-dependent, being true in some years and false in others,” Lewis added.
The total deaths on the mountains compared to the number of people accessing them gives us each mountain’s death rate. “Comparing death rates is more accurate than absolute values,” Salisbury told Africa Check.
As a rough indication of Table Mountain’s death rate, we’ll use the number of people going up the Table Mountain Cableway as a proxy.
Since the cableway opened its doors in 1929, it has welcomed 26 million users up to January 2017. During this period, an estimated 228 deaths occurred. This gives a death rate of 0.01 deaths per 1,000 visitors.
Between 1900 and 2017, Mount Everest was scaled by 23,487 people, including 11,262 guides, according to Salisbury’s figures. This results in a death rate of 12 deaths per 1,000 climbers. – Gopolang Makou (11/1/2018)
|UPDATE: “Using cable way visitors is the worst comparison to make, [as] their behaviour profile is totally different to people accessing the mountain on foot,” Lewis said following publication. “Let’s assume that the number of people accessing Table Mountain on foot is 1/10th of this number, this gives a value of 0.1 per 1,000 visitors for Table Mountain. Even at this number, Everest is still 140 times more deadly than Table Mountain.”|
© Copyright Africa Check 2019. You may reproduce this piece or content from it for the purpose of reporting and/or discussing news and current events. This is subject to: Crediting Africa Check in the byline, keeping all hyperlinks to the sources used and adding this sentence at the end of your publication: “This report was written by Africa Check, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the original piece on their website", with a link back to this page.