IN SHORT: The claim that a South African opposition party is manufacturing identity documents for foreigners has been doing the rounds on social media, ahead of the country going to the polls in 2024. But there’s no evidence for this.
“EFF Office in Hillbrow is manufacturing fake South African ID's in big numbers, so that Zimbos and Nigerians will vote for EFF in 2024,” reads a message circulating on social media in South Africa since December 2023 and into January 2024.
It adds that this is “the reason why EFF is fighting Operation Dudula because Operation Dudula is actually disturbing EFF vision”.
The Economic Freedom Fighters, or EFF, is a major South African opposition party. The country is set to hold elections some time in 2024.
Hillbrow is a densely populated suburb of apartment blocks in the inner city of Johannesburg, South Africa’s largest city. It has long been the first port of call for migrants. Since the 1980s these have mainly been people from other African countries.
Operation Dudula is a movement that opposes migration into South Africa from elsewhere on the continent. It is widely recognised as being xenophobic. “Dudula” is isiZulu for “force out” or “knock down”. In 2023 it registered as a political party.
As proof of its claim, the message shows photos of dozens of official papers such as passports and identity documents – known locally as IDs – lined up on a floor. Many versions use a screenshot of an X (formerly Twitter) post from April 2022.
The message implies that the EFF is making fake IDs for migrants so that they will vote for the party in the upcoming elections.
But were the photos really snapped in the EFF’s “office in Hillbrow”?
Hillbrow flat raided, suspect charged with fraud
Africa Check ran the photos through Google Lens, which finds exact matches for images elsewhere on the web.
It says a “tip-off from the community” led to the arrest of a 47-year-old Zimbabwean citizen found with more than 95 “fraudulent documents” in a Hillbrow flat on 14 April. The statement includes one of the photos.
The documents included IDs, birth certificates, passports, bank statements, Covid-19 certificates, work permits and gun licences. The suspect was charged with fraud.
The statement doesn’t mention the EFF.
The SAPS also posted photos of the raid on X. They are the same photos used in the claim.
The X post reads: “Gauteng Police Commissioner welcomes community #TipOff that lead to the arrest of a suspect , aged 47, found with fraudulent documents at a flat in Hillbrow on 14/04.”
#sapsGP Gauteng Police Commissioner welcomes community #TipOff that lead to the arrest of a suspect , aged 47, found with fraudulent documents at a flat in Hillbrow on 14/04. #CommunityPolicing MEhttps://t.co/WJQZF3cL5E pic.twitter.com/Fn9GeuGZAw— SA Police Service 🇿🇦 (@SAPoliceService) April 15, 2022
The photos were taken in a flat in Hillbrow raided by police, not an EFF office. There’s no evidence the party is “manufacturing fake South African ID's in big numbers”.
Republish our content for free
For publishers: what to do if your post is rated false
A fact-checker has rated your Facebook or Instagram post as “false”, “altered”, “partly false” or “missing context”. This could have serious consequences. What do you do?
Click on our guide for the steps you should follow.Publishers guide
Africa Check teams up with Facebook
Africa Check is a partner in Meta's third-party fact-checking programme to help stop the spread of false information on social media.
The content we rate as “false” will be downgraded on Facebook and Instagram. This means fewer people will see it.
You can also help identify false information on Facebook. This guide explains how.