Cayley Clifford and Lloyd Hazvineyi ANALYSIS: Are South Africa’s public hospitals ‘overburdened’ by foreign patients?

With elections looming in South Africa the debate about migration is again hotting up. But do foreign nationals take up hospital beds meant for locals?

South Africa’s health system was “overburdened” by having to care for more people than it could afford, health minister Aaron Motsoaledi said at a nurses’ summit on 14 November 2018.

In an interview with SAfm’s Stephen Grootes the next day, the minister blamed this on inadequate funding and “the issue of foreign nationals”.

Grootes asked if there were statistics on the share of foreign nationals using public healthcare. Motsoaledi said the health department did not officially collect this data as it was a “very sensitive matter”.

But he did say he had “a lot of anecdotal data”, such as the number of “not South African” babies born at three public hospitals – two in Gauteng province and one in Limpopo.

The minister said he “did not want to raise any debate or storm” but was “just mentioning the facts which nurses are dealing with every day”.

Expectant mother turned away from Gauteng hospitals

Motsoaledi’s first example was from Charlotte Maxeke Academic Hospital in Johannesburg. He said “two years ago” it was accused of being one of three hospitals that turned away a pregnant “Burundian woman”, who later gave birth at an inner city train station.

The incident was “in June that year”, the minister said. But in May the hospital “helped deliver 700 babies – and 400 of them were not South African at all”.

Census enumerators record the birth of a baby at the Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital in Soweto in 2011. Photo: AFP/ALEXANDER JOE
Census enumerators record the birth of a baby at the Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital in Soweto in 2011. Photo: AFP/ALEXANDER JOE

Lungiswa Mvumvu, a spokesperson for Charlotte Maxeke, told Africa Check that in May 2016, the hospital recorded “838 births, 200 of which were to non-South African citizens”.

But the incident the minister was referring to took place in June 2017 not June 2016,  And the woman involved came from the Democratic Republic of the Congo, not Burundi.

In May 2017 the hospital said it listed 771 births, 381 of which were to mothers from outside South Africa.      

Many foreign mothers ‘don’t go for treatment’

Motsoaledi then told Grootes that “on Christmas, 60% of the babies” delivered at the Steve Biko Academic Hospital in Pretoria were “not South African”.

The minister meant Christmas Day in 2017, national health department spokesperson Popo Maja told Africa Check.

Maja said Steve Biko was a referral hospital, which took in patients suffering complications. For women giving birth, these complications could be a result of them not getting healthcare during their pregnancy.

“Most people sent to Steve Biko are usually in critical condition. Many are foreign nationals who do not go for prenatal treatment as they are undocumented and so they often have birthing complications.”

Steve Biko hospital spokesperson Lovey Mogapi told Africa Check that six babies were born in the hospital on 25 December 2017. Only one was to a foreign mother.

‘Foreign’ babies born in border hospitals

Motsoaledi also said that when the head – or MEC – of Limpopo province’s health department visited Messina (also known as Musina) Hospital recently, “out of 10 babies that were delivered, seven were not South Africans”.

We have not been able to confirm the date of the MEC’s visit with her office. But “on average per week, the hospital delivers about 21 babies”, department spokesperson Neil Shikwambana told Africa Check.

“Out of those, 11 are foreign nationals and 10 are South Africans.” Shikwambana could not tell us how this average was calculated.

At face value, that means more than half the babies born at the hospital are “not South African”. This is lower than the 70% claimed by Motsoaledi.

We asked Lorena Nunez Carrasco, an associate professor in the department of sociology at Wits University, if she could explain.

“It makes sense,” she said. “If you need to give birth and there is a better service right there, a few kilometres away, but it belongs to another country, then you would go.”

Messina Hospital in northern Limpopo is just 15 kilometres from the Zimbabwe border. It’s also within reach of people from Mozambique to the east, and Botswana to the west.

Do foreign mothers ‘flood’ South Africa to give birth?

Carrasco said there was “no rationality behind this idea that women are flooding the country to give birth”. Her areas of study include how social and cultural factors affect health.

There might be “a few cases”, but these were only in border cities. And, she said, the people who did migrate were often the physically strongest and often have family or some other connection to South Africa.

“You don’t have many frail or sick people migrating… migrants don’t make irrational decisions. To travel at eight or nine months pregnant is risky and costly.”

What of Motsoaledi’s examples from the two Gauteng hospitals? These were “not extraordinary” and in line with global averages, Carrasco said.

“One has to first take into account the size of the migrant population in South Africa. It varies from three to five percent of the total population.”

Gauteng was home to over a quarter (25.4%) of South Africa’s population, so most migrants were likely to live there, Carrasco said.

Identifying ‘foreign’ babies

But how do officials know a baby is “not South African”?

Patients were identified as foreign nationals if they were unable to produce identification or proof of residence, or could not speak English or other local languages, the national health department’s Maja said.  

But there were weaknesses in this approach, Jo Hunter-Adams, a researcher at the University of Cape Town’s Health Economics Unit, told Africa Check.

“Hospital staff would not necessarily recognise all South African languages and those who are ill may not be able to communicate.”

Does being born in South Africa make you a citizen?

In South African law, there are three ways a person can become a citizen: birth, descent or naturalisation. The basic idea is that a child gets the citizenship of their parents. If one parent is a South African citizen, the child will be a South African citizen by birth.

But unlike in the United States, “you are not, by virtue of your birth, automatically entitled to South African citizenship”, Jennifer Woker, a partner at Shepstone and Wylie Attorneys, told Africa Check.

Woker’s expertise includes family and immigration law.

A notice of birth will be issued, which may then be taken to the country of origin or relevant embassy for a birth certificate or passport. The notice of birth, however, is not the same as a South African birth certificate.

“As a general rule, in the event that the child’s parents are foreigners on a work or similar visa, the child will have to apply for an accompanying visa to his/her parents’ visas, wait for a period of five years and thereafter be capable of applying for permanent residency,” Woker said.

“Once that’s obtained it’s a further 10 years before they can apply for citizenship.”

The same applies to children of registered refugees. The issue, Woker said, is when undocumented foreigners give birth in South Africa. Their children couldn’t be given a notice of birth, making it difficult for them to apply for a passport or leave the country.

What impact do migrants have on the health system?

“At a national level, very little,” Jo Veary, associate professor with the African Centre for Migration & Society, told Africa Check. Among her research works is how health development in South Africa is affected by migration.

South Africa did have progressive laws, Veary said. But in practice migrants from elsewhere in Africa were not attracted to South Africa for the quality of its healthcare system.  

“Individuals know that the system is not functioning at the level it should be, and people know that the treatment received as foreign nationals is poor.”

Hunter-Adams agreed that many migrants found it difficult to get public healthcare in South Africa.  

She said there was a “national discourse” that encouraged “medical xenophobia”.

“The narrative that foreign nationals are a ‘burden’ to the South African health system seems to be an example of scapegoating, where migrants are blamed for broader systemic problems with the health system.”


 

© Copyright Africa Check 2019. You may reproduce this piece or content from it for the purpose of reporting and/or discussing news and current events. This is subject to: Crediting Africa Check in the byline, keeping all hyperlinks to the sources used and adding this sentence at the end of your publication: “This report was written by Africa Check, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the original piece on their website", with a link back to this page.

Comment on this report

Comments 1
  1. By Carolyn Callow

    My Mozambican gardener returned from his annual holidays with Cerebral Malaria. He could not get adequate medical attention in his hometown hospital. He stayed in a state hospital in Gauteng for almost six months. He had 2 Cat scans , umpteen blood tests and xrays. Plus free medicines and later Specialist appointments that only cost him R120 per visit.
    He would have died if he had stayed in his country… but he does not pay taxes to support the care he received. So how can this sort of treatment be sustainable?

    +1
    -1
    vote
    Reply Report comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Africa Check encourages frank, open, inclusive discussion of the topics raised on the website. To ensure the discussion meets these aims we have established some simple House Rules for contributions. Any contributions that violate the rules may be removed by the moderator.

Contributions must:

  • Relate to the topic of the report or post
  • Be written mainly in English

Contributions may not:

  • Contain defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or harassing language or material;
  • Encourage or constitute conduct which is unlawful;
  • Contain material in respect of which another party holds the rights, where such rights have not be cleared by you;
  • Contain personal information about you or others that might put anyone at risk;
  • Contain unsuitable URLs;
  • Constitute junk mail or unauthorised advertising;
  • Be submitted repeatedly as comments on the same report or post;

By making any contribution you agree that, in addition to these House Rules, you shall be bound by Africa Check's Terms and Conditions of use which can be accessed on the website.

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.